Poison Milk Shot (Jägermeister & Baileys Layered Shooter)

A layered shooter that combines Jägermeister’s herbal kick with the smooth sweetness of Baileys Irish Cream. This easy Jägermeister shot recipe delivers bold flavor and striking presentation in every pour.

Poison Milk Recipe Image

The Poison Milk Shot is a bold layered shooter that stacks Jägermeister’s herbal intensity against the creamy sweetness of Baileys Irish Cream. Easy to make yet visually striking, this two-part shot has become a late-night party favorite thanks to its unusual flavor balance and eye-catching layers.

What You’ll Need

Ingredients

  • Jägermeister – the herbal backbone with notes of spice, citrus, and roots.
  • Baileys Irish Cream – smooth, sweet cream liqueur that softens the bitter edge.

Equipment

  • Shot glass (chilled for best effect)
  • Bar spoon (for layering)

Cream Meets Herbs: Why It Works

This shooter pairs opposites—bitter herbs and silky cream—for a sip that surprises and satisfies. Its layered look makes it a conversation starter, while the flavors blend into a rich, slightly bittersweet finish.

Substitutions & Variations

  • Swap the base: Try Fernet-Branca or another amaro for a stronger herbal punch.
  • Go dairy-free: Use Baileys Almande or coconut cream with vanilla for a vegan-friendly twist.
  • Flavor boost: Add a splash of coffee liqueur for mocha vibes, or peppermint schnapps for holiday flair.

Helpful Tips

  • Chill both spirits before layering for cleaner separation.
  • Pour the Baileys slowly over the back of a spoon to float it neatly.
  • For garnish, dust with cocoa or cinnamon, or drop in a single coffee bean.
  • Serve immediately—layered shots don’t hold their shape long.

Poison Milk Recipe

Type of Glass

Shot Glass

Ingredients

  • 1 part
  • 1 part

Directions

  1. Chill a shot glass in the freezer for a few minutes.
  2. Pour 1 part Jägermeister into the glass.
  3. Slowly layer 1 part Baileys Irish Cream over the back of a spoon so it floats on top.
  4. Serve immediately.

The Poison Milk Shot is proof that bold flavors and simple layering can create something unforgettable in a single sip.

You may also like

Shots & Shooters
B-52

B-52

Learn how to make the classic B-52 shot—a stunning layered shooter made with coffee liqueur, Baileys Irish Cream, and orange liqueur. This easy cocktail recipe is famous for its striking layers and indulgent flavor, making it a must-try for party lovers and home bartenders.

Shots & Shooters
Buttery Nipple

Buttery Nipple

The Buttery Nipple is a popular shot that has gained a reputation for its sweet, creamy flavor and smooth texture. This delightful concoction is a favorite among party-goers and cocktail enthusiasts alike, often served at bars and social gatherings. The drink's name is as playful as its flavor, evoking images of indulgence and fun.

Shots & Shooters
Black Hole

Black Hole

The world of cocktails and shots is a vast universe filled with a myriad of flavors, colors, and experiences. Among the many concoctions that have emerged over the years, the "Black Hole" shot stands out as a visually striking and flavorful choice. This shot combines the herbal complexity of Jägermeister® with the intense minty freshness of Rumplemintz®, creating a drink that not only tantalizes the taste buds but also captivates the eyes.

Beginner-FriendlyTwo-Ingredient CocktailsHerbal CocktailsCreamy CocktailsParty CocktailsJägermeister CocktailsLayered ShotsBaileys CocktailsEasy Shots